Issue 2 (75)
| THE BAIKAL COUNTER-VERSION AND SOVIET SCIENCE EXPERTISE: A HISTORY OF ONE SEISMOLOGICAL DISPUTE (1962–1963) | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Year | 2022 | Number | 2(75) |
| Pages | 78-87 | Type | scientific article |
| UDC | 94(571.5)“1962/1963”:910.3(571.5) | BBK | 63.3(253.5)632 |
| Authors | Piskunov Mikhail O. |
Topic | SOVIET ENVIRONMENTAL KNOWLEDGE |
| Summary | The paper examines some beginning events of the Baikal discussion using the STS approach. The author addresses the disputes about seismicity of the Baikal Pulp and Paper Mill (PP M) and Selenga Paper Mill sites in 1962–1963 to identify the specifics of Soviet expertise and the role of the Siberian Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences as an expert. In February, 1962, the Siberian Branch approached the Council of Ministers of the USSR with the proposal to reject the construction of pulp and paper mills on Baikal because of the increased seismic hazard of the selected sites. The scientists of the Siberian Branch of the Academy of Sciences defined the latter as 10 points, after which the State Construction Committee banned further construction of the Baikal PP M until this circumstance was clarified. Finally, the government commission and additional construction experts estimated the sites of both plants at 9 points. The attempt of the Siberian Branch to challenge this conclusion was not successful. The author reconstructs the events of this counter-version and concludes that in the sphere of expertise the political moment of the Baikal discussion manifested itself not in the positions of the parties and not even in their arguments, but in the ability of government institutions to determine when the discussion was possible and when it should have stopped. | ||
| Keywords | Baikal Ñontroverse, Baikal Pulp and Paper Mill, experts, Siberian Branch of the Academy of sciences, environmentalism, STS | ||
| References |
Breyfogle N. B. At the Watershed: 1958 and the Beginnings of Lake Baikal Environmentalism. Slavonic and East European Review, 2015, vol. 93, no. 1, pp. 147–180. DOI: 10.5699/slaveasteurorev2.93.1.0147 (in English). Jasanoff Sh. The fifth branch: science advisers as policymakers. Cambridge; London: Harvard University Press, 1990. (in English). Josephson P. New Atlantis Revisited: Akademgorodok, the Siberian city of Science. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1997. (in English). Kochetkova E. Baikal Waters: Industrial Development and Institutional Debates, 1950s–1970s. Place and Nature: Essays in Russian Environmental History. Winwick: White Horse Press, 2021, ch. 13, pp. 292–313. (in English). Kochetkova E. Between water pollution and protection in the Soviet Union, mid-1950s–1960s: Lake Baikal and River Vuoksi. Water History, 2018, vol. 10, iss. 2-3, pp. 223–241. DOI: 10.1007/s12685-017-0208-z (in English). Kuznetsov I. S. Akademgorodok v 1975 godu: kak ukhodil Lavrent’yeva: opyt istoricheskoy rekonstruktsii [Akademgorodok in 1975: how Lavrentyev was leaving: an experience of historical reconstruction]. Novosibirsk: Klio Publ., 2005. (in Russ.). Latur B. Nauka v deystvii: sleduya za uchenymi i inzhenerami vnutri obshchestva [Science in Action: How to Follow Scientists and Engineers Through Society]. Saint Petersburg: Evropeyskiy universitet v Sankt- Peterburge Publ., 2013. (in Russ.). Lubomudrov S. Environmental Politics in the Soviet Union: The Baikal Controversy. Canadian Slavonic Papers, 1978, vol. 20, iss. 4, pp. 529–543. DOI: 10.1080/00085006.1978.11091546 (in English). Stehr N., Grundmann R. Experts: The Knowledge and Power of Expertise. London: Taylor & Francis Group, 2011. (in English). Veblen T. B. Inzhenery i tsenovaya sistema [The engineers and the price system]. Moscow: Izd. dom VShE Publ., 2018. (in Russ.). Vek Lavrent’eva [The Age of Lavrentyev]. Novosibirsk: Geo Publ., 2000. (in Russ.). Weiner D. R. A Little Corner of Freedom. Russian nature Protection from Stalin to Gorbachev. Berkeley; Los Angeles; London: University of California Press, 1999. (in English). Yurchak A. Eto bylo navsegda, poka ne konchilos’. Posledneye sovetskoye pokoleniye [Everything Was Forever, Until It Was No More: the Last Soviet Generation]. Moscow: Novoye literaturnoye obozreniye Publ., 2014. (in Russ.). |
||
| Download in PDF | |||
